Judges up for retention
60 judges are on every Cook County ballot, in Chicago and the suburbs (1 Appellate, 59 Circuit). Each needs at least 60% Yes to keep their seat (Illinois Constitution, Art. VI, Sec. 12). The Yes and No numbers shown are from Chicago ballots; suburban Cook ballots may number them differently. Judges in DuPage, Kane, Kendall, Lake, McHenry and Will counties aren't covered yet.
John J. Mahoney: Withdrew in September. The Board left this judge's ballot numbers (247-248) unused, so the name isn't on Chicago ballots. Some guides still list this judge. Chicago Board of Elections ↗
Where the ratings come from. Fourteen bar groups screen these judges: the 13 members of the Alliance of Bar Associations for Judicial Screening and the Chicago Bar Association. We show each group's own rating, taken from its own publication. This guide doesn't rate judges.
A group rates a judge who skips its screening “Not Recommended,” so a No can also mean the judge didn't take part.
Bar groups recommend nearly every sitting judge. This year 4 of 60 got any “No.” Open a judge to see what the evaluators wrote, including concerns behind a “Yes,” and anything a newsroom or official record reported.
Showing 60 of 60, in ballot order
1.Bertina E. LampkinAppellate Court · Chicago ballot Yes 201, No 202On the bench since 1987 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Associate judge from 1987, elected circuit judge 1992; appointed to Appellate Court 2009, elected 2016
- Now
- Illinois Appellate Court, First District
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1974-1985; City of Chicago Law Department 1985-1987
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys praise her knowledge, ability and passion for the law and call her opinions well written and detailed; described as collegial and gracious.“collegial, collaborative and gracious” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Finds she exceeds the Council's higher standard for appellate judges; lawyers report strong command of the law, well-reasoned opinions and good temperament.“exceptional command of substantive law” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported she was lead prosecutor in Stanley Wrice's 1983 case; his conviction was vacated in 2013 over police-abuse claims. Claims against her in his civil suit were dismissed; she denies wrongdoing. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Well Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
2.Lewis NixonCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 203, No 204On the bench since 2001All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2001, elected 2002
- Now
- Supervising judge, Chancery Division mortgage foreclosure and mechanics lien section
- Before
- HUD regional counsel 1983-2001; railroad and private litigation; federal prosecutor
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Received positive comments in all areas evaluated; described as knowledgeable, kind, respectful, calm, collegial and diligent. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Very good legal ability and courtroom management, and gives self-represented litigants a chance to be heard; some respondents say he can be slow to rule.“he can be slow to rule” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
3.Kerry M. KennedyCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 205, No 206On the bench since 2002 · 3 reported itemsAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2002
- Now
- Presiding judge, Fifth Municipal District (Bridgeview), since 2021
- Before
- Cook County assistant public defender 1979-2002
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys praise his in-depth legal knowledge and pragmatism; considered well prepared with high integrity.“ability to be pragmatic” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Considered a knowledgeable judge doing a good job in his current assignment. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court reversed his dismissals of two murder convicts' postconviction petitions in the past term, ordering a hearing in one in 2022. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch, citing the Sun-Times and court records, reported that in 2016 he raised a defendant's bond from $2,000 to $50,000 without explanation and sneered in court at the appellate ruling cutting it; after the defense moved to replace him, he recused. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch, citing the Tribune, reported that in a 2006 trial he said he might hold a sexual assault victim in contempt for not watching a video, then reversed course a day later. He did not respond to requests for comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
4.Joan E. PowellCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 207, No 208On the bench since 2006 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2006, elected 2008
- Now
- Law Division, civil jury trials
- Before
- Cook County civil prosecutor 2000-2006; judicial law clerk; solo practice
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Lawyers and judges rated her legal knowledge, sensitivity to diversity, professionalism, impartiality and temperament excellent; described as hardworking, diligent and punctual. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Considered to have good legal ability; reported to be hardworking with a good temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court in 2025 vacated a $43.8 million verdict from her courtroom over how she questioned jurors, ordering a new trial before another judge. She said she followed the jury instructions and now polls jurors individually. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
5.Maureen Ward KirbyCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 209, No 210On the bench since 2007 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2007, elected 2008
- Now
- Presiding judge, County Division
- Before
- Commercial litigator in private practice, 1989-2008
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Highly regarded by attorneys for legal knowledge, integrity, even-handedness and handling a wide range of legal issues. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Brief review: notes about 12 years of practice and 19 on the bench and her own view that she is a good judge; no lawyer comments summarized. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court in 2025 ordered her to reopen a ranked-choice voting lawsuit she had dismissed in 2024, because Evanston was not a party; the refiled case is before her. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
6.Edward A. ArceCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 211, No 212On the bench since 2008 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2008, elected 2008 (14th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division
- Before
- Civil practice at a small firm, 1985-2008
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys report that his decisions are based on the law and that he is diligent and prompt. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Most respondents call him excellent; some say he can be so procedure-driven that he misses chances to resolve cases early.“so procedurally driven that he misses opportunities to resolve cases early” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court reversed his dismissal of a paternity case against musician Buddy Guy; he then ordered a new paternity test in July. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
7.Thomas J. ByrneCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 213, No 214On the bench since 2008 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2008
- Now
- Felony cases, Criminal Division, Leighton Criminal Courthouse
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1989-2008
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys praise his fairness and demeanor; respected by both sides as a judge who follows the law. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability, courtroom management and well-reasoned rulings; described as fair to all parties.“low-key, effective demeanor” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court overturned his rulings at least 16 times last term, including a 2025 reversal for barring body-camera video from a jury. He declined to comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
8.Diana L. KenworthyCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 215, No 216On the bench since 2008 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2008
- Now
- Felony trial call, Criminal Division, Leighton Criminal Courthouse
- Before
- Assistant public defender 1996-2000; private practice and court arbitrator 2000-2008
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
High praise from attorneys for legal knowledge, ability to handle complex cases, integrity and professionalism. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and courtroom management; adept at handling the many unrepresented parties in her courtroom. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported that her 2022 bench acquittal of Jimmy Jackson on charges of murdering Daisy Hayes, whose body was never found, drew criticism from Hayes' family that continues; she declined to comment through a spokesperson. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
9.Kristyna Colleen RyanCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 217, No 218On the bench since 2008All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2008
- Now
- Presiding judge, Fourth Municipal District (Maywood); mental health and veterans treatment courts
- Before
- Private civil practice
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Knowledgeable, fair to everyone and especially good with self-represented litigants; punctual, diligent and professional. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Had little litigation experience when elected and faced a substantial learning curve; lawyers now call her hardworking with good legal knowledge.“faced a substantial learning curve” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
10.Ursula WalowskiCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 219, No 220On the bench since 2008 · 1 reported itemAll 13 groups: Yes · 1 not reported
Background
- Path
- Elected 2008
- Now
- Felony trial call, Criminal Division, Leighton Criminal Courthouse
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1994-2008
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Comments cite poor temperament and impatience; she is also praised for legal knowledge, willingness to research and courtroom management.“poor temperament and impatience” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Seen as fair, diligent and knowledgeable; some report she treats attorneys and litigants harshly, and most accept her impatience and flare-ups.“impatience and flare-ups” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court overturned her rulings at least 25 times in her latest term, including a 2023 ruling calling her handling of a self-represented murder defendant "a complete failure." She cited high caseloads and said she respects the appellate court.“a complete failure” Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Not yet reported: Cook County Bar Association.
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Alliance update, Oct. 6, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
11.Anthony C. "Tony" KyriakopoulosCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 221, No 222On the bench since 2010 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2010, reappointed 2012, elected 2014
- Now
- Chancery Division, mortgage foreclosure and mechanics lien section
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1990-2010
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys report he is professional, good at explaining the law to self-represented litigants and treats everyone equally. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Reported to have good legal ability and temperament; the review mostly covers his prosecutor years, when he was praised as honest and zealous. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch, citing the Tribune, reported he dropped out of a 2012 primary against a party-favored candidate and was then reappointed by the Illinois Supreme Court. He did not respond to a request for comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
12.Caroline Kate MorelandCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 223, No 224On the bench since 2010 · 2 reported itemsAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2010, reappointed 2012, elected 2014
- Now
- Chancery Division, complex civil cases
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1996-2010
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Said to be prepared and knowledgeable, fair to everyone and considerate of self-represented litigants; manages her courtroom well. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
The review describes her prosecutor years, when she was considered to have good legal ability and temperament; it summarizes no comments on her judging. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported that in a recording played at Ed Burke's 2023 corruption trial, Burke cited ties to her father and said he helped make her a judge. She declined to comment.“We made his daughter a judge here in Cook County” Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch, citing the Tribune, reported she dropped out of a 2012 primary against a party-favored candidate and was then reappointed by the Illinois Supreme Court. She told the Tribune she made no deals.“That was a personal and political decision that I made” Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
13.Thomas J. CarrollCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 225, No 226On the bench since 2011 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2011, reappointed 2012, elected 2014
- Now
- Supervising judge, misdemeanor and traffic cases, Sixth Municipal District (Markham)
- Before
- Assistant public defender; criminal defense practice 1992-2011
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys praise his judicial skills and legal knowledge, describing him as respectful, professional and calm. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability; praised for his temperament and fairness, with rulings reported to be well-reasoned and thoughtful. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch, citing the Tribune, reported he dropped out of a 2012 primary and was reappointed by the Illinois Supreme Court. Injustice Watch added that his exit helped a candidate with negative bar ratings and that he has family ties to disgraced former Ald. Ed Burke, whose wife sat on that court. He said, "Judge me on my record."“Judge me on my record” Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
14.Andrea M. BufordCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 227, No 228On the bench since 2013 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2013, elected 2014 (the CCL report gives 2011 for her appointment)
- Now
- Presiding judge, Child Protection Division
- Before
- Civil litigator in private practice 1987-2013; state hearing officer; Court of Claims commissioner
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys and judges call her highly knowledgeable, approachable and even-tempered, able to handle emotionally charged cases well. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability, good temperament and broad experience; considered hardworking and always well prepared. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported that, as a lawyer for the city in a 2007 federal civil rights trial brought by former federal agents alleging retaliation, she defended a former officer already convicted of racketeering, whom his prosecutor called the district's most corrupt; the jury awarded $9.75 million. She declined to comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
15.John Michael AllegrettiCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 229, No 230On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed May 2014, elected November 2014
- Now
- Civil non-jury trials, First Municipal District
- Before
- Counsel to the Cook County Treasurer and Assessor; county civil prosecutor 2001-2005
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys praise his legal knowledge, research skills, professionalism and fairness. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and praised as hardworking, with a professional, even-tempered demeanor. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch, citing the Tribune, reported he helped a 2012 push to ban liquor sales in a Galewood precinct that critics questioned as racially motivated. He disputes that account, citing residents' noise concerns. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
16.Kristal R. RiversCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 231, No 232On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed June 2014, elected 2014
- Now
- Misdemeanor and domestic violence courtroom, Bridgeview
- Before
- Assistant Illinois attorney general 2010-2014; private practice; Texas prosecutor 1996-2000
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Said to be knowledgeable with fair, thoughtful rulings; respectful, calm, consistent and sensitive to the diverse people before her. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good knowledge of the law; manages her courtroom efficiently and with respect for everyone. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court reversed several of her juvenile-division decisions, finding parts of some probation conditions too broad, such as orders to scrub gang and drug activity from social media; she has not been reversed since moving to Bridgeview in 2021. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
17.Steven G. WatkinsCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 233, No 234On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed May 2014, elected November 2014
- Now
- Supervising judge, Criminal Division, Leighton Criminal Courthouse
- Before
- Criminal defense, civil and real estate practice 1991-2014
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Praised for legal knowledge, diligence, professionalism and temperament; fair to both sides, prepared and punctual.“universally praised for his legal knowledge, diligence, professionalism and temperament” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
The review centers on his trial experience as a lawyer; he is seen as diligent, with a low-key, professional demeanor. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported he was arrested on a drunken driving charge in 2012 and acquitted of it in 2013, with a $200 fine for failing to reduce speed. He declined to comment on the arrest. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
18.Abbey Fishman RomanekCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 235, No 236On the bench since 2014 · 2 reported itemsAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed August 2014, elected November 2014 (9th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Supervising judge, Domestic Relations Division
- Before
- Civil litigator at several firms; Illinois Attorney General's office fraud unit
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Said to be knowledgeable, efficient, punctual and fair-minded. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
High marks for legal knowledge and professionalism; most praise her temperament, but a few say she can get irritable when litigants ignore her rules.“could occasionally get irritable” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported a 2024 federal suit over her barring a litigants' adult son from a Zoom hearing was dismissed on judicial immunity, with an appeal pending. She said she keeps non-litigant children out of court. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch reported attorneys called her curt and easily annoyed, some saying she seemed unprepared and delayed cases, though most called her fair. She said she prepares for every case and keeps a judicial demeanor. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
19.Judith C. RiceCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 237, No 238On the bench since 2014All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014
- Now
- Presiding judge, Domestic Violence Division
- Before
- BMO Harris executive; deputy chief of staff to Mayor Daley; Chicago city treasurer
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Described as knowing the law well and giving fair hearings; brings sensitivity to diversity and bias, once immediately addressing a litigant's derogatory remark. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Considered very smart, with a very good temperament and high professionalism; praised as an excellent administrator. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
20.Patrick Kevin CoughlinCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 239, No 240On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014
- Now
- Felony courtroom, Sixth Municipal District (Markham)
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1996-2014, including narcotics
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys call him very knowledgeable and up to date on case law, and very fair and respectful to all. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
The review covers his prosecutor career, when he was praised for good legal ability and temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court in 2025 overturned his 38-year sentence for a man who killed someone at 17, finding an abuse of discretion; one justice dissented. He declined to comment on the pending case. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
21.Megan Elizabeth GoldishCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 241, No 242On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014 (9th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Domestic Violence Division
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1997-2014
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys highly praise her legal knowledge, patience, diligence and fairness. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and temperament; praised as hardworking and knowledgeable, and the review cites her prosecutor work in a felony diversion program. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported two men she charged as a prosecutor, one later exonerated and one acquitted, sued alleging statements she prepared were false and signed under duress; claims against her proceeded, one was dropped and one suit settled in 2024 for $2.4 million. She calls her role peripheral. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
22.Anjana M.J. HansenCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 243, No 244On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014 (9th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Deputy presiding judge and felony courtroom, Second Municipal District (Skokie)
- Before
- Evanston administrative hearing officer and alderman; private practice; Cook County prosecutor
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys praise her legal knowledge, research abilities, impartiality and thoroughness. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Considered to have good legal ability and temperament and to be very active in community activities. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court ruled in 2026 that she should not have denied a certificate of innocence to Frank Drew, who was exonerated in 2024 after 24 years in prison. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
23.Robert D. KuzasCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 245, No 246On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014
- Now
- Felony preliminary hearings, Branch 44, First Municipal District
- Before
- Private practice in criminal defense, personal injury and labor cases
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys call him a knowledgeable judge who applies the law carefully and is professional and diligent. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and temperament; reported to be exceptionally hardworking and knowledgeable. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch, citing the Sun-Times, reported that in 2014 he ran in the West Side 7th Subcircuit, created to help elect Black judges, after temporarily renting an apartment on its edge. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
24.Maritza MartinezCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 249, No 250On the bench since 2014 · 5 reported itemsAll 11 groups: Yes · 3 not reported
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014 (countywide)
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division, Daley Center
- Before
- Private practice; City of Chicago Law Department; Court of Claims commissioner
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Most attorneys describe her as diligent, hardworking and eager to see families succeed, and as someone who could be stern.“someone who could be stern” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Competent, thorough, hardworking, direct and efficient; generally described as stern but fair, despite a few negative comments from respondents.“stern but fair” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported that at a July 2025 county board hearing, several litigants accused her of insensitivity and bias toward domestic violence survivors; she had already recused from one speaker's case. She did not respond to requests for comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch reported litigants and advocates complained that she ordered a woman to mediation with her ex despite acknowledging an order of protection that should have prevented mediation. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch reported another woman unsuccessfully sought her removal after she reinstated an ex's parenting time despite his arrest for allegedly assaulting his girlfriend in front of their child (charges later dropped); she recused about a month after the hearing. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch reported attorneys called her unpredictable at best; even lawyers who like practicing before her said she tends to lose her temper and "go off" on people. She did not respond to requests for comment.“go off” Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch reported attorneys who dislike appearing before her called her rude, biased against domestic violence survivors and self-represented litigants, and inappropriately emotional in her decisions; others found her fair, hardworking and knowledgeable. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Not yet reported: Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Cook County Bar Association.
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Alliance update, Oct. 6, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
25.Terrence J. McGuireCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 251, No 252On the bench since 2014All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014
- Now
- Probate Division, Decedent Estates Section
- Before
- Solo practice in estate planning, probate and real estate; administrative law judge
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Overwhelmingly positive feedback on his legal knowledge and ability, level-headedness and grasp of complex matters. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Had little complex-litigation or probate experience when assigned, but worked to close the gap; now seen as knowledgeable, fair, respectful and decisive. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
26.Bridget Anne MitchellCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 253, No 254On the bench since 2014All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014
- Now
- Law Division, civil jury trials
- Before
- Civil defense litigator, 1981-2014
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Excellent legal knowledge; impartial, calm and respectful with high integrity; some attorneys thought she moved cases too slowly.“some attorneys thought she moved cases too slowly” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Reviews her extensive civil trial experience as a lawyer; considered to have good legal ability and temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
27.James P. PieczonkaCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 255, No 256On the bench since 2014 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014 (12th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Civil cases, Third Municipal District (Rolling Meadows)
- Before
- Solo practice and real estate development; state administrative law judge 1985-1996
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Comments were positive; described as well prepared, consistent, patient, professional, fair, diligent and efficient. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Had limited litigation experience when elected, but lawyers say he overcame it; praised for preparation and thorough, high-quality rulings.“limited litigation experience when he was elected” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported he lost three properties in foreclosure sales between 2013 and 2020 and went through personal bankruptcy. He said the experience taught him to resolve cases promptly. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
28.Patricia O'Brien SheahanCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 257, No 258On the bench since 2014All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2014
- Now
- Law Division, Trial Section
- Before
- Associate general counsel, Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago 1999-2014; litigation associate at Baker & McKenzie
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Said to be knowledgeable, always prepared and sensitive to diversity; impartial, professional and hardworking, with a pleasant, consistent demeanor. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability; praised for the quality of her work and considered knowledgeable and always prepared. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
29.Michael A. FortiCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 259, No 260On the bench since 2016 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2016 and 2018; associate judge 2019-20; elected 2020
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division, individual calendar
- Before
- IDOT chief counsel 2012-2015; Chicago deputy corporation counsel; commercial litigation partner
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys call him highly skilled in domestic relations, issuing well-reasoned decisions while being respectful and patient. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Very positive marks as a judge; handles a high-volume call and treats self-represented litigants respectfully without overstepping the judge's role. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported he has held a man in jail for civil contempt since 2022 over a $10 million divorce award; the man's lawyer faults him, but the appellate court affirmed him in 2025. He says he followed the law. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
30.Nichole C. PattonCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 261, No 262On the bench since 2018All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2018, elected 2020
- Now
- Law Division, Trial Section
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor handling mental health commitments 2010-2018; private practice
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
A supermajority of respondents praised her legal knowledge, sensitivity, temperament, character and diligence. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability; considered knowledgeable, and previously praised as a zealous advocate who was trustworthy and respectful to clients and opposing counsel. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
31.Sondra N. DenmarkCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 263, No 264On the bench since 2018All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2018, elected 2020
- Now
- Supervising judge, First Municipal District trial section
- Before
- Will County prosecutor 2008-2018; Cook County prosecutor 2004-2007
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Positive feedback on her legal knowledge, firm grasp of case law and ability to explain things to jurors and self-represented litigants. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Considered to have good legal ability and temperament and substantial litigation experience. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
32.Gerardo Tristan, Jr.Circuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 265, No 266On the bench since 2019 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020
- Now
- Civil jury courtrooms, First Municipal District
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 2003-2019; associate at a business law firm
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Comments on his legal knowledge, sensitivity, temperament, diligence and integrity were all positive. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and substantial complex-litigation experience; reported to have a good temperament, and respondents praised his fairness. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported his parents' caregiver sued him and his brother in 2023 over unpaid pay and his conduct; it settled in May 2024. He denies being intoxicated or stopping her from leaving. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
33.Lynn Weaver BoyleCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 267, No 268On the bench since 2019All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020
- Now
- Chancery Division, general chancery
- Before
- Commercial litigation partner 1999-2019; Cook County prosecutor 1990-1999
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Comments on her legal knowledge, sensitivity, integrity, temperament and preparedness were positive. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and substantial trial experience; a respected practitioner with a good temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
34.Daniel Edward MaloneyCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 269, No 270On the bench since 2019All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020
- Now
- Preliminary hearings plus drug, mental health and veterans treatment courts, Sixth Municipal District (Markham)
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor from 2001, including a federal drug-trafficking strike force
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Comments on his legal knowledge, sensitivity, character, temperament and diligence were all positive. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
The review covers his prosecutor years: good legal ability, praised courtroom skills and temperament, and an excellent mentor to newer lawyers. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
35.Thomas M. CushingCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 271, No 272On the bench since 2019 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020
- Now
- Law Division jury trials
- Before
- Civil litigator; Chicago Climate Exchange executive 2006-2010
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys praise his legal knowledge and ability, diligence, integrity and even-keeled temperament. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
The review covers his law practice: a solid practitioner with very good ability, strong litigation skills and an excellent temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court in 2022 reversed his denial of a protective order, calling his error "considerable." He said he learned from the ruling and discussed it with fellow judges.“considerable” Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
36.John G. MulroeCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 273, No 274On the bench since 2019All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020
- Now
- Juvenile Justice Division
- Before
- Illinois state senator 2010-2019; private practice; Cook County prosecutor; CPA
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
All comments on his legal knowledge, sensitivity, temperament, diligence and character were very favorable. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
As a lawyer, considered to have good legal ability, respected for his trial skills and integrity, with a very good temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
37.Tyria B. WaltonCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 275, No 276On the bench since 2019 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020
- Now
- Felony trials, Criminal Division, Leighton Criminal Courthouse
- Before
- Cook County assistant public defender 1998-2019, including murder cases
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
References uniformly praised her legal knowledge, temperament, character and professionalism. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Very good legal ability and substantial complex-litigation experience; praised for trial skills, diligence and integrity, and considered exceptionally knowledgeable. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported her 2024 acquittal of a woman who dragged a police officer with his squad car angered police allies; she said she received threats and ruled on the evidence and law. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
38.Erin Haggerty AntoniettiCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 277, No 278On the bench since 20191 of 14 groups: No
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020
- Now
- Misdemeanor courtroom, Sixth Municipal District (Markham)
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 1994-2019, mostly in central bond court; insurance defense associate
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys say she has good legal knowledge, gives thorough rulings and is prepared and punctual. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
As a judge, reported to show good legal ability and temperament and the ability to manage high-volume courtrooms. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said No
- Cook County Bar Association
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
39.Teresa Molina-GonzalezCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 279, No 280On the bench since 2019 · 1 reported item1 of 14 groups: No
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020 (countywide)
- Now
- Rotating courtrooms, Fourth Municipal District (Maywood)
- Before
- Chief of real estate prosecutions, state Department of Financial and Professional Regulation 2016-2019; Cook County prosecutor 2001-2016
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys report she is knowledgeable, researches her cases, and is level-headed and respectful. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability; considered a good judge in her limited time on the bench, after earning good marks as a hardworking prosecutor. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported she faced intense criticism in 2025 after a man she released before trial was accused of setting a woman on fire on a CTA train. She did not respond to requests for comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said No
- Cook County Bar Association
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
40.Patricia Maria FallonCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 281, No 282On the bench since 2019 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020 (12th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division
- Before
- HR chief, Cook County Recorder of Deeds 2017-2019; county labor and employment litigator 2004-2017
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys report strong legal knowledge and analytical ability; well respected for her preparedness and fairness. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and state and federal litigation experience; described as hardworking with a good temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported her 2020 opponent sued for a recount after her 502-vote win; he lost in state court, his federal suit was dismissed, and an appeal is pending. She declined to comment on the pending case. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
41.Sheree D. HenryCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 283, No 284On the bench since 2019All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, elected 2020 (countywide)
- Now
- Fourth Municipal District (Maywood)
- Before
- Cook County assistant public defender 1999-2019; assistant public guardian 1995-1999
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Overall feedback is that she is a good judge who mainly follows the law and is honest, respectful and calm.“a good judge who mainly follows the law” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and substantial criminal trial experience; respondents generally call her a good lawyer with good trial skills. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
42.Celestia L. MaysCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 285, No 286On the bench since 2019All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019, associate judge 2020, elected 2020 (countywide)
- Now
- Misdemeanor and traffic cases, Fourth Municipal District (Maywood)
- Before
- Solo practice in family law, probate and real estate
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys consider her patient, respectful and a good researcher with good legal knowledge. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Very good legal ability, with praised temperament and litigation skills; reported to be an excellent practitioner with great integrity. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
43.Levander Smith, Jr.Circuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 287, No 288On the bench since 2019 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Appointed 2019; associate judge (December 2019 per CCL, January 2020 per ISBA); elected 2020 (countywide)
- Now
- Child Protection Division
- Before
- DCFS attorney; Missouri assistant attorney general; Cook County prosecutor
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Describes his child protection docket and his volunteer work with youth leaving foster care; the narrative summarizes no attorney comments on his judging. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Substantial litigation experience and good legal ability; praised for his trial skills and reported to have a good temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court in 2022 reversed his removal of an incarcerated mother from a Zoom hearing about her child, while saying it meant no criticism. He said he would now act differently. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
44.Julie Bess AimenCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 289, No 290On the bench since 2020 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (9th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division
- Before
- Solo practice in criminal defense, family, civil rights and appellate law; assistant appellate defender
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys consider her smart, hardworking, professional and patient with the many self-represented litigants before her. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Very good legal ability and good temperament, with extensive complex-litigation experience.“Her integrity is unquestioned.” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported two litigants criticized her at a July 2025 county board hearing; its review found her mediation order noted both sides agreed, and she granted the fee waiver that week. She cited ethics rules in declining comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
45.Laura Ayala-GonzalezCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 291, No 292On the bench since 2020All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020
- Now
- Felony call, Criminal Division, Leighton Criminal Courthouse
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 2003-2020
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys and judges praise her legal knowledge and ability; considered fair, effective, diligent and prepared.“one of the stronger jurists in the Criminal Division” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability, praised trial skills from her prosecutor years, and a very good temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
46.Krista D. ButlerCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 293, No 294On the bench since 2020 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (1st Subcircuit, unopposed)
- Now
- Civil jury section, First Municipal District
- Before
- Attorney roles at state agencies, including DCFS
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Described as hardworking with a good grasp of legal issues who takes time to understand all sides; commended for patience with self-represented litigants. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Respondents call her fair and hardworking; respectful to all litigants and especially praised for handling self-represented litigants. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported she ran unopposed in 2020 without taking part in bar evaluations and did not respond to its repeated requests for information. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
47.Marie Aileen DempseyCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 295, No 296On the bench since 2020All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (10th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Law Division, Motion Section
- Before
- Medical malpractice and insurance defense litigator 2002-2020
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Described as very smart, with immense legal knowledge and integrity; considered diligent.“slow to anger” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability; praised for her temperament and litigation skills, with substantial complex-litigation experience. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
48.Jamie Guerra DicklerCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 297, No 298On the bench since 2020All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020
- Now
- Probate Division, minor guardianship
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 2005-2020
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys call her highly knowledgeable, patient with self-represented litigants and thoroughly prepared on complex matters. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Praised for her legal ability and integrity; reported to be highly professional and always well prepared. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
49.Jonathan Clark GreenCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 299, No 300On the bench since 2020 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (8th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Law Division, Commercial Calendar
- Before
- City of Chicago Law Department senior counsel on civil rights cases; private civil practice
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys spoke highly of his legal knowledge and ability, temperament and character.“the bench could use more like him” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Many see him as knowledgeable with good legal ability; most respondents report that he has a good temperament. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported that he and the city Law Department, where he was a supervisor, were criticized for withholding police-abuse evidence; it found no instance of him being individually accused in court. He declined to comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
50.Mary Catherine MarubioCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 301, No 302On the bench since 2016All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Associate judge 2016, elected circuit judge 2020
- Now
- Presiding judge, Second Municipal District (Skokie); deputy chief judge, First Appearance Court
- Before
- State professional-regulation prosecutor, administrative law judge and ethics officer; criminal defense and immigration practice
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Attorneys comment favorably on her legal knowledge and ability, preparedness, fairness and sensitivity. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Considered a smart, solid practitioner with varied litigation experience; praised for her temperament and for mastering several areas of law. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
51.Regina A. MescallCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 303, No 304On the bench since 2020 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division, Fifth Municipal District (Bridgeview)
- Before
- Cook County felony prosecutor until 2020; earlier a New Mexico prosecutor
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Comments on her temperament, sensitivity and preparedness were uniformly positive; concerns were raised about her legal knowledge and impartiality in her new domestic relations assignment.“concerns voiced about her legal knowledge and impartiality” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability; the review focuses on her prosecutor career, praising her litigation skills and professional demeanor. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court in 2025 reversed her $75,000 eviction judgment, saying she should have held an evidentiary hearing in a case of first impression. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
52.Lorraine Mary MurphyCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 305, No 306On the bench since 20202 of 14 groups: No
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020
- Now
- Felony cases and drug treatment court, Second Municipal District (Skokie)
- Before
- Cook County prosecutor 2003-2020
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Not recommended: good knowledge of criminal law, but concerns about impartiality favoring the prosecution and careless preparation of her evaluation questionnaire.“lack of impartiality in criminal cases in favor of the prosecution” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and a good temperament; praised for trial skills, with substantial complex-litigation experience. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said No
- Cook County Bar Association
- Illinois State Bar Association
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
53.Eileen Marie O'ConnorCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 307, No 308On the bench since 2020All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (6th Subcircuit)
- Now
- Law Division, Trial Section
- Before
- Civil litigator in personal injury, medical malpractice and related cases
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
All comments on her legal knowledge, temperament, sensitivity, diligence and character were positive. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability; praised as hardworking, with a good temperament, and considered diligent and punctual. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
54.Jill Rose QuinnCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 309, No 310On the bench since 2020All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (countywide)
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division
- Before
- Private practice in real estate, family and civil cases; court arbitrator
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Comments were uniformly positive about her legal knowledge, sensitivity, temperament, character and diligence. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and temperament, with substantial litigation experience in complex areas. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
55.Pamela Reaves-HarrisCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 311, No 312On the bench since 2020 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (7th Subcircuit)
- Now
- First Municipal District, housing and civil cases
- Before
- Illinois state representative 2015-2017; municipal administrative law judge; Cook County legal affairs aide
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Praised for her legal knowledge, sensitivity, character, diligence and temperament. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Smart and knowledgeable, with an exemplary temperament; in 2020 the Council worried about her limited litigation experience but judged she could be a good judge.“concerned that she had little litigation experience” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported that in 2019 she publicly objected after Justice Anne Burke cited a CBA finding of limited experience in appointing someone else; she won the seat in 2020. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
56.Tiesha L. SmithCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 313, No 314On the bench since 2020 · 1 reported item6 of 14 groups: No
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (countywide)
- Now
- Juvenile Justice Division
- Before
- Cook County assistant public defender 2010-2020; civil practice
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Not recommended: reports of screaming matches between the judge and attorneys and minor respondents raise concerns about her temperament and effectiveness.“screaming matches between the Judge and attorneys” Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Generally good reviews in child protection, but since a 2024 transfer, problems reported with temperament and attendance; found qualified after seeking her agreement to take a stress-management course.“adopted a hostile temperament” Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported she ran in 2018 and 2020 without taking part in bar evaluations. She said she lacked the experience for a qualified rating in 2018 and her earlier ratings still applied in 2020. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said No
- Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area
- Decalogue Society of Lawyers
- Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois
- Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois
- Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association
- Illinois State Bar Association
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
57.Chris StaceyCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 315, No 316On the bench since 2020 · 3 reported itemsAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020
- Now
- Civil jury section, First Municipal District
- Before
- Solo civil litigation practice from 1992
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Describes his civil assignments and his volunteer work with World Relief; the narrative summarizes no attorney comments on his judging. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and trial skills, a professional temperament, and praised for his diligence and integrity. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported the appellate court in 2026 vacated his criminal contempt order jailing a self-represented man in an eviction trial, saying his own remarks worsened the man's frustration. He did not respond to a request for comment. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch reported he owns rental properties while hearing eviction cases, and is suing the city over a 2023 sidewalk fall. Injustice Watch ↗
Injustice Watch reported his 2020 race involved a possible "sham candidate"; he denied any involvement at the time.“sham candidate” Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
58.Perla TiradoCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 317, No 318On the bench since 2020 · 1 reported itemAll 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020
- Now
- Civil jury room, First Municipal District
- Before
- Legal aid supervising attorney 2016-2020; criminal defense and immigration practice; assistant public defender
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Favorable comments on her diligence, temperament, sensitivity and character; noted for doing her own research and issuing written rulings. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and knowledge of the law, a good temperament and substantial litigation experience in varied areas. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Injustice Watch reported some bar groups found her not qualified in 2020, citing limited complex-litigation experience; attorneys who appear before her now call her balanced, patient and fair. Injustice Watch ↗
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
59.Elizabeth Anne WalshCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 319, No 320On the bench since 2020All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020
- Now
- Law Division, Motion Section
- Before
- Insurance defense attorney 2006-2020
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Those familiar with her work were uniformly positive about her legal knowledge, sensitivity, temperament, diligence and character. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability, praised temperament and substantial litigation experience. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.
60.Maura McMahon ZellerCircuit Court · Chicago ballot Yes 321, No 322On the bench since 2020All 14 groups: Yes
Background
- Path
- Elected 2020 (countywide)
- Now
- Domestic Relations Division, individual calendar
- Before
- Child representative and guardian ad litem practice; assistant public guardian for 10 years
From Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers, Injustice Watch.
What the evaluators wrote
Illinois State Bar Association
Interviewees rated her legal knowledge, diligence, sensitivity and character good, with temperament a particular strength. Illinois State Bar Association ↗
Chicago Council of Lawyers
Good legal ability and praised temperament; her practice area was narrow, but she is highly respected for her knowledge and skills. Chicago Council of Lawyers ↗
Reported controversies, reversals or discipline
Nothing noted in Injustice Watch's review (checked Oct 29, 2026).
Bar group ratings
Said Yes: Arab American Bar Association, Asian American Bar Association of the Greater Chicago Area, Black Men Lawyers' Association, Black Women Lawyers' Association of Greater Chicago, Cook County Bar Association, Decalogue Society of Lawyers, Hellenic Bar Association of Illinois, Hispanic Lawyers Association of Illinois, Chicago's LGBTQ+ Bar Association, Puerto Rican Bar Association, Women's Bar Association of Illinois, Illinois State Bar Association, Chicago Council of Lawyers (Qualified), Chicago Bar Association (Qualified)
Ratings from Alliance of Bar Associations, Illinois State Bar Association, Alliance of Bar Associations, Chicago Bar Association, retrieved Oct 29, 2026.